5 Best Jarlsberg Cheese Substitutes (Honest Picks)

No ratings yet

Use a 1:1 ratio substitute and adjust only if your swap is softer (strain/drain) or stronger (add a mild cheese blend).

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Prep Time 5

Cook Time 0

Total Time 5

Servings: 1 batch

Course: Substitutes

Best Matches

1:1 Swiss cheese (Emmental-style, good melting) Closest overall flavor family; slice-thin for fast, even melt.
1:1 Gruyère (young-to-medium, nutty) More nutty/roasty; start with ¾:1 if you want the mildness closer.

Good Alternatives

1:1 Havarti (buttery, mild) Softer and creamier mouthfeel; great for sandwiches and grilled cheese.
1:1 Edam (semi-hard, mild-sweet) Gentle sweet flavor; melts well but may be slightly less “stretchy.”
1:1 Provolone (mild, melt-friendly) Smoother melt; choose “mild” for a closer flavor profile.

Emergency Swaps

1:1 Mozzarella (whole milk, low-moisture for best bake melt) Mild and stretchy; blend with Swiss/Edam if you want stronger nutty notes.
1:1 Muenster (very mild, buttery) Easy melt but can taste bland; add a small pinch of ground mustard or black pepper.

Decide your use: cold snack/sandwich (flavor + slice quality) vs baking (melt + browning).
Pick the closest flavor family first (Swiss-style or Gruyère), then match melt behavior (Havarti/Provolone/Mozzarella).
Use a 1:1 swap by weight; if the substitute is stronger (Gruyère), start at ¾:1 and top up with a milder cheese.
For oven baking, shred or slice thin so the cheese melts evenly and doesn’t pool.
Taste the finished dish once melted; adjust seasoning (pepper/ground mustard) if the swap tastes flatter than jarlsberg.

Flavor intensity varies by brand/age; for closer jarlsberg mildness, blend a stronger swap with Swiss or Edam.
Thin slicing/shredding improves melt and reduces greasy separation.

Let us know how it was!