Skip to Content

5 Best Fiori Di Sicilia Substitutes to Consider

Are you stuck for ideas about what could replace Fiori di Sicilia in your baking recipes? Look no further.

We’ve got all the information you need to know, plus five great replacements.

Let us give you the confidence to create delicious recipes without the worry of having to find Fiori di Sicilia.

You won’t want to miss this.

What’s Fiori Di Sicilia?

Fiori Di Sicilia is a delightful Italian flavoring made with oranges, lemon zest, and vanilla extract.

It’s the perfect way to add an interesting twist to your favorite desserts like cakes, ice cream, and waffles.

This lusciously-scented Italian flavor has a robust aroma that elevates the taste of almost any sweets it is added to.

In terms of its taste, Fiori Di Sicilia has subtle notes of citrus as well as a hint of sweetness from the vanilla extract.

The texture is smooth and creamy due to the addition of high-quality ingredients.

When it comes to utilizing this delightful flavoring, the possibilities are endless.

Whether you’re baking cookies or making homemade ice cream sandwiches, adding Fiori Di Sicilia will take your creation to the next level.

With its bold flavor and aroma, it quickly transforms ordinary desserts into extraordinary treats.

5 Best Fiori Di Sicilia Substitutes to Consider

If you don’t have Fiori Di Sicilia readily available in your pantry or find it too expensive to buy, here are 5 great substitutes that you can use for a similar flavor.

1 – Orange Extract

Orange extract is one of the most common and closest substitutes for Fiori di Sicilia, as it provides an oil-based profile similar to Fiori.

Orange extract can help bring out the sweetness of a dish while also providing a hearty dose of citrus notes.

It is an oil-based extract, which means that it requires extra time and proactive stirring when added to batters.

A little orange extract goes a long way, so you should use much less than the amount recommended for fiori di sicilia in your recipe.

Additionally, if you are looking for a more subtle flavor, consider using orange zest instead of orange extract for a milder flavor.

2 – Vanilla Extract

Vanilla extract is the simplest, most straightforward substitute for Fiori di Sicilia.

It will give you the flavor of vanilla and orange that Fiori di Sicilia provides.

However, it lacks the sweetness from the Florio alcohol in it.

To get a similar effect, you can add a bit of honey or other liquid sweetener to it if desired.

Be sure to use pure vanilla extract rather than imitation for the best results.

Start by using just a little bit at a time as too much vanilla will overpower most recipes.

3 – Millefiori Extract

Millefiori extract is a type of essence derived from wildflowers, specifically the sweet scented variety that grows in Sicilia.

This versatile extract can be used in place of Fiori di Sicilia for an authentic flavor.

Like with Fiori de Sicilia, it has a certain amount of sweetness, though it’s not as intense as Fiori de Sicilia.

The flavor profile is reminiscent of vanilla and citrus combined with floral tones and hints of nutmeg.

It’s a great alternative that can be used to add sweet flavors to cakes, ice creams or other baked goods or desserts.

As with all extracts, use sparingly to get the best results.

4 – Lemon Extract

Lemon extract is a flavor enhancer and can be used as a substitute for Fiori di Sicilia.

It’s made from the oils of lemons and won’t provide any authentic Sicilian flavors, but will bring tartness and brightness to your recipe.

Add it in small amounts, tasting as you go, until you achieve the desired flavor.

This is a great option for light sponge cakes or panna cotta with candied peel for a citrusy finish.

Just be sure to use pure lemon extract if you can – avoid anything “imitation”.

5 – Orange Blossom Water

Orange blossom water is a fragrant liquid made from the distilled blossoms of the orange tree.

The scent and flavor of orange blossom water are very similar to Fiori di Sicilia but it is much lighter.

Its floral flavor is most noticeable in baked goods such as cakes and cookies, but it can also be used in savory dishes like salads or marinades for fish.

Because it is so versatile, orange blossom water makes an excellent substitute for Fiori di Sicilia.

Keep in mind that a little goes a long way – you only need a few drops to get the same flavor.


In conclusion, Fiori Di Sicilia is a fragrant, orange blossom-based flavoring originally developed to enhance Italian desserts such as panettone.

Its unique flavor makes it a great addition to all sorts of treats, including cookies and cupcakes.

However, finding this flavor might be difficult for many consumers and so there are some good substitutes available.

By understanding the flavor profile of Fiori Di Sicilia and its alternatives you can create delicious sweet treats that are sure to please your friends and family members.

Whether you’re baking a traditional Italian dessert or experimenting with a modern twist on an old favorite — understanding what goes well together is key to creating yummy snacks.

5 Best Fiori Di Sicilia Substitutes to Consider

5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Course Substitutes


  • 1 – Orange Extract
  • 2 – Vanilla Extract
  • 3 – Millefiori Extract
  • 4 – Lemon Extract
  • 5 – Orange Blossom Water


  • Choose your preferred substitute from the list of options.
  • Organize all of your ingredients.
  • Use the proper substitute to cook your recipes.
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!