5 Best Brioche Bread Substitutes (Ranked)

No ratings yet

Use this quick guide to swap enriched breads for brioche while keeping texture and sweetness close to the original.

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Prep Time 5

Cook Time 0

Total Time 5

Servings: 1 batch

Course: Substitutes

Best Matches

1:1 Challah (enriched, eggy bread) Closest overall softness; slightly less buttery than brioche but still tender—works great for French toast and stuffing.
1:1 Milk bread / shokupan (soft, lightly sweet) Very pillowy crumb; best when you want a softer slice that soaks evenly.

Good Alternatives

1:1 Egg bread (sweet sandwich bread) High egg content for richness—watch for extra sweetness depending on brand.
¾:1 Panettone (sweet enriched loaf) Sweeter and more aromatic; use slightly less or reduce added sugar in the recipe.
1:1 Croissant (flaky, buttery layers) Adds buttery crunch/flake—best for French toast tops or layered dishes, not for uniform cubes.

Emergency Swaps

1:1 White sandwich bread + butter-milk soak Most neutral; mimic brioche by soaking with a butter-milk mixture before baking/serving.

Identify your use: toast/French toast (soak-friendly) vs stuffing/cubes (even texture) vs sandwiches (slice and spread).
Choose the closest ranked bread: Challah for general purpose, milk bread for the softest crumb, or egg bread for similar richness.
If the substitute is sweeter (panettone), reduce added sugar by about 25–33%; if it’s drier/denser (white sandwich bread), increase soak time.
Cut consistently: cubes or slices of similar size so the substitute soaks and browns evenly.
Taste and adjust after baking: add a small pinch of salt or a tiny splash of dairy to rebalance sweetness and richness.

Brioche’s payoff comes from enrichment (butter/eggs) and soft, tender crumb—match richness first, then adjust sweetness and soak.

Let us know how it was!