Go Back
–+ servings
5 Best Wisconsin Brick Cheese Substitutes | EpicureDelight

5 Best Wisconsin Brick Cheese Substitutes

No ratings yet
Use the closest texture-and-melt match to Wisconsin Brick Cheese by choosing a swap by recipe goal: melting, slicing, or baking browning.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 0 minutes
Total Time 5 minutes
Servings: 1 batch
Course: Substitutes
Ingredients Equipment Method Notes

Ingredients
  

Best Matches
  • 1:1 Provolone (low-moisture, deli style) Melt-friendly with mild tang; works especially well for casseroles and baked melts.
  • 1:1 Cheddar (medium, shredded) Closest overall flavor direction; shred for faster melting and more even coverage.
Good Alternatives
  • 1:1 Colby Jack (blend, shredded) Similar sliceable chew plus smoother melting; good for sandwiches and baked mac-style bakes.
  • 1:1 Gouda (young or mild, shredded) Creamy melt with buttery notes; best when you want a softer, less sharp result.
Emergency Swaps
  • 1:1 Monterey Jack (mild, shredded) Reliable melt when you’re short on time; add a pinch of salt or a small squeeze of lemon if needed.
  • ¾:1 ratio American cheese (processed slices, thinly layered) Very smooth melt for toasties; use slightly less because it can overpower flavor and turn oily.

Equipment

  • Cheese grater (for shredding)
  • Cutting board and knife (for slicing)
  • Measuring cup or kitchen scale (for consistent ratios)

Method
 

  1. Identify your use case (melting/baking vs slicing/sandwich) and pick the closest match from the list above.
  2. Use the listed substitution ratio; shred or slice thinly so the cheese melts evenly.
  3. If your swap is milder than Wisconsin Brick Cheese, add a small pinch of salt to the dish before baking.
  4. For swaps that melt faster, start checking doneness 3–5 minutes early to avoid greasiness.
  5. Taste the hot dish: if it needs more tang, mix in a tiny amount of sour cream or a few drops of lemon juice (by teaspoon) in the sauce.

Notes

  • Shredding improves melt texture for most swaps.
  • Use slightly less American cheese because it can dominate and get oily.
  • For tang-forward results, prefer cheddar or provolone and adjust seasoning to taste.

Tried this recipe?

Let us know how it was!